TAX AND BRAIN DRAIN: JUSTIFICATION, POLICY OPTIONS AND PROSPECT FOR LARGE DEVELOPING ECONOMIES

B. Bawono Kristiaji

Sažetak


International migration has continued to escalate over the last three decades, creating a risk of brain drain in developing countries. This paper reviews the extent to which the use of tax instruments to address brain drain can be justified in developing economies with large populations. Furthermore, it explores and assesses tax policy options that may be undertaken to prevent the emigration of high-skilled individual, namely the Bhagwati tax proposal, exit tax, revenue sharing and tax incentives.

Five things can be concluded from the assessment of several policy choices. First, there is no stand-alone tax policy that can optimally address brain drain, in the sense of reducing the number of high-skilled individuals who emigrate. Second, most policies put more focus on the element of fairness to compensate for the “loss” caused by the home country. Third, almost every available policy requires better coordination at the international level. Fourth, all policy options require closer collaboration with immigration agencies. Finally, each policy has the potential to produce unintended consequences.


Pojmovne odrednice


Brain drain; Large developing economies; Bhagwati tax; Exit tax; Tax incentive.

Reference


Adonnino, Pietro. 1993. General Report. 22 in Non-discrimination rules in international taxation. IFA Cahier Vol. 78b.

Adamson, Fiona B. 1/2006. Crossing Borders: International Migration and National Security. The MIT Press 31: 165–199.

Agunias, Dovelyn R., Kathleen Newland. 2012. Developing a Road Map for Engaging Diasporas in Development: A Handbook for Policymakers and Practitioners in Home and Host Countries. Geneva: International Organization for Migration.

Ahmed, M. Mushtaque. 2019. Bangladesh – Individual Taxation. IBFD Country Surveys: 12.

Arslan, Cansin, Jean-Christophe Dumont, Zovanga L. Kone, Çağlar Özden, Christopher R. Parsons, Theodora Xenogiani. 2016. International Migration to the OECD in the 21st Century. KNOMAD Working Paper 16: 26–29.

Avi-Yonah, Reuven S. 2015. And Yet It Moves: Taxation and Labor Mobility in the Twenty-First Century. 45–56 in Taxation and Migration, edited by Reuven S. Avi-Yonah and Joel Slemrod. The Netherlands: Wolters Kluwer Law & Business.

BBC News. 2019. Nigeria: Why Is It Struggling to Meet Its Tax Targets? https://www.bbc.com/news/world-africa-49566927 (last visited 3 October 2019).

Beine, Michel, Frederic Docquier, Caglar Ozden. 2009. Diasporas. Policy Research Working Paper 4984.

Beine, Michel, Frederic Docquier, Hillel Rapoport. 2001. Brain Drain and Economic Growth: Theory and Evidence. Journal of Development Economics: 275–289.

Beine, Michel, Frederic Docquier, Hillel Rapoport. 2008. Brain Drain and Human Capital Formation in Developing Countries: Winners and Losers. The Economic Journal 118: 631–652.

Beretta, Giorgio. 8/2017. Italy – From Worldwide to Territorial Taxation: Is Italy Now an Attractive Destination for Migrating Individuals?. Bulletin for International Taxation 71.

Beretta, Giorgio. 1/2019. Cross-Border Mobility of Individuals and the Lack of Fiscal Policy Among Jurisdictions (Even) After the BEPS Project. Intertax 47: 107–110.

Bhagwati, Jagdish N., Koichi Hamada. 1/1982. Tax Policy in the Presence of Emigration. Journal of Public Economics 18: 291–317.

Bhagwati, Jagdish N. 1976. The International Brain Drain and Taxation: A Survey of the Issues. 34–38 in The Brain Drain and Taxation: Theory and Empirical Analysis, edited by Jagdish N. Bhagwati. Amsterdam: North Holland.

Bhagwati, Jagdish N. 3/1979. International Migration of the Highly Skilled: Economics, Ethics, and Taxes. Third World Quarterly 1: 28.

Bhagwati, Jagdish N., William Dellalfar. 1–2/1973. The Brain Drain and Income Taxation. World Development 1: 94–101.

Brauner, Yariv. 1/2010. Brain Drain Taxation as Development Policy. Saints Louis University Law Journal 55: 45.

Brücker, Capuano, Marfouk (2013). Education, gender and international migration: insights from a panel-dataset 1980–2010, mimeo.

Buchanan, John, Lucilla McLaughlin. 2017. Revenue Administration: Implementing a High-Wealth Individual Compliance Program. Technical Notes and Manuals: 8–9.

Cavallini, Simona, Rosella Soldi, Lorenzo Di Matteo, Beatrice Errico. 2018. Addressing Brain Drain: The Local and Regional Dimension. European Union.

Cejie, Katia. 6/2012. Emigration Taxes – Several Questions, Few Answers: From Lasteyrie to National Grid Indus and Beyond. Intertax 40.

Chand, Vikram. 2013. Exit Charges for Migrating Individuals and Companies: Comparative and Tax Treaty Analysis. Bulletin for International Taxation 67.

Christians, Allison. 2/2017. A Global Perspective on Citizenship-Based Taxation. Michigan Journal of International Law 38.

Clemens, Michael A. 2014. A Case Against Taxes and Quotas on High-Skill Emigration. Working Paper 363.

Colombo, John D. 23/1998. A Proposal for an Exit Tax on Nonprofit Conversion Transactions. J. Corporation Law 779.

Crowley, George R., Adam J. Hoffer. 2018. Earmarking Tax Revenues: Leviathan’s Secret Weapon?. in For Your Own Good: Taxes, Paternalism, and Fiscal Discrimination in the Twenty-First Century, edited by Adam J. Hoffer and Todd Nesbit. Arlington, VA: Mercantus Center.

Dagan, Tsilly. 2018. International Tax Policy: Between Competition and Cooperation. United Kingdom: Cambridge University Press.

Dagan, Tsilly. 2013. The Tragic Choices of Tax Policy in a Globalized Economy. in Tax, Law and Development, edited by Yariv Brauner and Miranda Stewart. Northampton: Edward Elgar Publishing.

Darvas, Peter, Shang Gao, Bilal Bawany. 2017. Sharing Higher Education’s Beyond the Few in Sub-Saharan Africa. Washington, D.C.: The World Bank.

De Broe, Luc. 2002. The Tax Treatment of Transfer of Residence by Individuals. International Fiscal Association. De Hague: Kluwer Law International 2002.

Desai, Mihir A., Davesh Kapur, John McHale. 2004. Sharing the Spoils: Taxing the International Human Capital Flows. International Tax and Public Finance 11: 681–684.

De Man, Fernando, Tiiu Albin. 12/2011. Contradicting Views of Exit Taxation Under OECD MC and TFEU: Are Exit Taxes Still Allowed in Europe? Intertax 39.

Del Caprio, Ximena V., Caglar Ozden, Mauro Testaverde, Mathis Wagner. 2016. Global Migration of Talent and Tax Incentives: Evidence from Malaysia’s Returning Expert Program. Policy Research Working Paper 7875.

Dietsch, Peter. 2015. Catching Capital: The Ethics of Tax Competition. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Docquier, Frederic. The Brain Drain from Developing Countries. 2014. IZA World of Labor 31: 3–10.

Docquier, Frederic, Hillel Rapoport. 2011. Globalization, Brain Drain, and Development. IZA Discussion Paper Series 5590.

Docquier, Frederic, Hillel Rapoport. 2007. Skilled Migration: The Perspective of Developing Countries. IZA Discussion Paper Series 2873: 15–16.

Docquier, Frederic. 2006. Brain Drain and Inequality Across Nations. IZA Discussion Paper Series 2440.

Dos Santos, Manon D., Fabien Postel-Vinay. 1/2003. Migration as a Source of Growth. Journal of Population Economics 16: 161–175.

DSP-Groep. Study on the Levying and Collection of The Tax in Seven European Countries. https://www.dsp-groep.eu/projecten/the-2-pct-tax-for-eritreans-in-the-diaspora/ (last visited 2 October 2019).

Dumont, Jean-Christophe. Gilles Spielvogel, Sarah Widmaier. 2010. International Migrants in Developed, Emerging and Developing Countries: An Extended Profile. OECD Social, Employment and Migration Working Papers No.114. Paris.

Dumont, Jean-Christophe, Gilles Spielvogel. 2010. International Migrants in Developed, Emerging and Developing Countries: An Extended Profile. OECD Social, Employment and Migration Working Papers 114: 27.

Elveren, Adem Y. 2018. Brain Drain and Gender Inequality in Turkey. Switzerland: Springer International.

Egger, Hartmut, Josef Falkinger, Volker Grossman. 2007. Brain Drain, Fiscal Competition, and Public Education Expenditure. IZA Discussion Paper Series 2747.

European Commission. https://ec.europa.eu/taxation_customs/business/company-tax/anti-tax-avoidance-package/anti-tax-avoidance-directive_en (last visited 4 October 2019).

Fan, Simon C., Oded Stark. 2007. International Migration and Educated Employment. Journal of Development Economics 83: 76–87.

Gadzo, Stjepan, Irena Klemencic. 2/2017. Effective international information exchange as a key element of modern tax systems: Promises and pitfalls of the OECD’s common reporting standard. Public Sector Economics 41.

Gaspar, Vitor, Laura Jaramillo, Philippe Wingender. 2016. Tax Capacity and Growth: Is there a Tipping Point? IMF Working Paper WP/16/234. International Monetary Fund Department of Fiscal Affairs, Washington, D.C., USA.

Georgaki, Vera. 2010. Emigration Tax Consequences in Greece. European Tax Studies.

Gibson, John, David McKenzie. 2011. Eight Questions about Brain Drain. Policy Research Working Paper 5668: 3–5.

Goldin, Ian, Geoffrey Cameron, Meera Balarajan. 2012. Exceptional People: How Migration Shaped Our World and Will Define Our Future. New Jersey: Princeton University Press.

Gordon, Stephen. 2016. Bargaining Power and the Incidence of Income Taxes on High Earners in Canada, SSRN Electronic Journal

Grubel, Herbert B., Anthony D. Scott. 1966. The International Flow of Human Capital. American Economic Review 56: 273.

Grunkorn, Wolfram, H.T. Thi Do, Quynh N.T. Nguyen. 2019. Vietnam – Individual Taxation. IBFD Country Surveys: 7–8.

Guarcello, Lorenzo, Jean Fares, Marco Manacorda, Furio C. Rosati, Scott Lyon, Christina A. Valdivia. 2008. School-to-Work Transitions: Regional Overview. 109–148 in Youth in Africa’s Labor Market, edited by Marito Garcia and Jean Fares. World Bank Publications.

Gupte, Medha, Kiran Jadhav. 2014. The Concept of Reverse Brain Drain and Its Relevance to India. 1/2014. Journal of Research in Management & Technology 3: 83–87.

Hamzaoui, Ridha. 2019. Egypt – Individual Taxation. IBFD Country Surveys: 8.

Heckert, Jessica. 27/2015. New perspective on youth migration: Motives and family investment patterns. Demographic Research 33: 765–800.

Hellerstein, Walter. 1/2003. Jurisdiction to Tax Income and Consumption in the New Economy: A Theoretical and Comparative Perspective. Georgia Law Review 38: 36.

Holmes, Kevin. 2007. International Tax Policy and Double Tax Treaties. Amsterdam: IBFD.

Huntington, Samuel P. 2/1996. Democracy for the Long Haul. Journal of Democracy 7: 3–13.

IBFD. 2005. International Tax Glossary. Amsterdam: IBFD.

IMF. 2014. Spillovers in International Corporate Taxation. IMF Policy Paper.

IMF. 2018. Egypt: Time to Entrench Growth and Make it More Inclusive. IMF News. 23 January.

IMF. 18/2018. Article IV Consultation – Press Release and Staff Report. IMF Country Report 215: 33.

Jennings, Ralph. 2017. Vietnam’s Corruption Crackdown Is All about Protecting Its Economic Miracle From Its SOEs. Forbes. 19 December.

Kane, Mitchell A. 2/2015. A Defense of Source Rules in International Taxation. Yale Journal on Regulation 32.

Kapur, Devesh. 2004. Remittances: The New Development Mantra? G-24 Discussion Paper Series 29: 16.

Kating, Philippe-Alexandre S. M. 2019. Congo (Dem.Rep.) – Individual Taxation. IBFD Country Surveys: 8.

Kaul, Inge. 2016. Global Public Goods. Northampton: Edward Elgar Publishing.

Kauppinen, Ilpo, Olli Ropponen. 2018. Taxation, Migration and Location of Innovative Activity. Background Report for the Economic Policy Council.

Keen, Michael, Jenny E. Ligthart. 117/2004. Information Sharing and International Taxation. CentER Discussion Paper.

Koo, Angela. 2019. Indonesia – Individual Taxation. IBFD Country Surveys: 8.

Koo, Angela, H. Bukhari. 2019. Pakistan – Individual Taxation. IBFD Country Surveys: 12.

Kubicova, Jana. 2017. Exit Tax in the World of International Migration of Companies and Individuals. Conference Proceedings. 16th International Scientific Conference Globalization and Its Socio-Economic Consequences.

Larking. Barry. 2005. IBFD International Tax Glossary, 5th ed.: 115–162.

Lencho, Taddese. 2019. Ethiopia – Individual Taxation. IBFD Country Surveys: 10.

Lister, Matthew. 2016. A Tax-Credit Approach to Addressing Brain Drain. Saint University Law Journal 62.

Martin, George. 2019. Poland scraps income tax for an entire generation to reverse brain drain and entice its workers back home. Mail Online, 1 August.

Mason, Ruth. 2016. Citizenship Taxation. Southern California Law Review 89: 170–240.

Mazansky, Ernest. 5/2010. South Africa – South Africa’s Exit Charges (And Something on Immigration Too). Bulleting for International Taxation 64.

McCulloch, Rachel, Janet L. Yellen. 1975. Consequences of a Tax on the Brain Drain for Unemployment and Income Inequality in Less Developed Countries. Journal of Development Economics 2.

Ocampo, Jude. 2019. Philippines – Individual Taxation. IBFD Country Surveys: 12.

Odimma, Sebastine. 2019. Nigeria – Individual Taxation. IBFD Country Surveys: 8.

OECD. 2003. Model Tax Convention on Income and on Capital. Paris: OECD Publishing.

OECD. 2019. Harmful Tax Practices – 2018 Progress Report on Preferential Regimes. Paris: OECD Publishing.

OECD. 2018. Resumption of Application of Substantial Activities for No or Nominal Tax Jurisdictions – BEPS Action 5. Paris: OECD Publishing.

Ordine, Patrizia, Giuseppe Rose. 2011. Inefficient Self-Selection into Education and Wage Inequality. Economics of Education Review 30: 582–597.

Ozden, Caglar, Maurice Schiff. 2006. International Migration, Remittances, and the Brain Drain. Washington DC: Palgrave Macmillan.

Pistone, Pasquale, Jennifer Roeleveld, Johann Hattingh, Joao Felix Pinto N., Craig West. 2019. 10 in the component of the equity principle. Fundamentals of Taxation: An Introduction to Tax Policy, Tax Law and Tax Administration. The Netherlands: IBFD.

Pistone, Pasquale, Yariv Braune. 2015. BRICS and the Emergence of International Tax Coordination. The Netherlands: IBFD.

Pinto, Dale. 2007. Exclusive Source or Residence-Based Taxation – Is a New and Simpler World Tax Order Possible?. Bulletin for International Taxation. 61: 277–291

Pomp, Richard D. 1985. The Experience of the Philippines in Taxing Its Non-resident Citizens. Faculty Articles and Papers 77: 245–286.

Rannveig, Dovelyn, Kathleen Newland. 2012. Developing A Road Map for Engaging Diasporas in Development. Washington DC: International Organization for Migration.

Roudgar, Iraj. 2014. The Global Brain Drain: Theory and Evidence. Saarbrucken: Lambert Academic Publishing.

Roudgar, Iraj, Cameron K. Richards. 2015. The Policy Challenges of the Global Brain Drain: Addressing Dilemmas of Contributing Push-Pull Factors. International Journal of Public Policy 11: 73 – 85.

Schiff, Maurice. 2018. Brain Drain-Induced Brain Gain and the Bhagwati Tax: Are Early and Recent Paradigms Compatible? IZA Discussion Paper Series 11551.

Schwarzenhofer, Renate M. 2005. Dual Resident Companies in International Tax Law. 20 in Source versus Residence in International Tax Law, edited by Hans-Jorgen Aigner and Walter Loukota. Vienna: Linde Verlag.

Seid, Yared, Ali S. Alemayehu, Nuru Seid. 2016. Ethiopia: An Agrarian Economy in Transition, in Africa’s Lions: Growth Traps and Opportunities for Six African Economies. Washington D.C: Brookings Institution Press.

Shah, Shreyas. 2019. India – Individual Taxation. IBFD Country Surveys: 10.

Solimano, Andrés. 2013. Remittances by Emigrants: Issues and Evidence. CEPAL – SERIE Macroeconomía del desarrollo 26: 15.

Stark, Oded, Christian Helmenstein, Alexia Prskawetz. 2/1997. A Brain Grain with a Brain Drain. Economic Letters 55: 227–234.

Stewart, Aeris. 2019. Poland’s Youth Tax Cut Creates Dueling Incentives. Tax Foundation.

Tanzi, Vito. 2016. Lakes, Oceans, and Taxes: Why the World Needs a World Tax Authority. 256–259 in Global Tax Fairness, edited by Thomas Pogge and Krishen Mehta. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

TalentCorp. Returning Expert Programme for Malaysians Who Are Away From Home.

https://www.talentcorp.com.my/initiatives/returning-expert-programme (last visited 3 October 2019).

Thani, Rabi. 2006. Brain Drain in IDB Member Countries: Trends and Development Impact. IDB Occasional Paper 12.

The Heritage Foundation. 2019. Index of Economic Freedom: Democratic Republic of Congo. https://www.heritage.org/index/pdf/2019/countries/democraticrepubliccongo.pdf (last visited 4 October 2019).

Tiebout, Charles M. 10/1956. A Pure Theory of Local Expenditures. Journal of Political Economy Vol. 64 No. 5: 416–424.

United Nations. 2019. International Migrant Stock 2019. https://www.un.org/en/development/desa/population/migration/data/estimates2/estimates19.asp. (last visited 2 October 2019).

United Nations. 2013. World Youth Report on Youth & Migration. New York: United Nations Publication.

United Nations. 1948. Universal Declaration of Human Rights

Wagner, Don. 2000. Do Tax Differences Cause the Brain Drain. Policy Options.

Wamsley, Terrie L., Alan L. Winters. 2005. Relaxing the Restrictions on the Temporary Movement of Natural Person. Journal of Economic Integration 20: 688–726.

Wilson, John D. 2011. Brain-Drain Taxes for Non-benevolent Governments. Journal of Development Economics 95: 68–76.

Wilson, John D. 2008. A Voluntary Brain-Drain Tax. Journal Public of Economics 92: 2385–2391.

World Bank. Age Dependency Ratio. 2019. World Development Indicators. https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/ny.gdp.mktp.kd.zg (last visited 3 October 2019).

World Bank. GDP Growth. 2019. World Development Indicators. https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SP.POP.DPND (last visited 3 October 2019).

World Bank. 2017. Publication: Nigeria Economic Update: Beyond Oil, Key Drivers for Sustainable Growth. https://www.worldbank.org/en/country/nigeria/publication/nigeria-economic-update-beyond-oil-key-drivers-for-sustainable-growth (last visited 2 October 2019).

World Bank. 2018. India Development Update: India’s Growth Story. New Delhi: The World Bank Publishing.

World Bank. 2019. Pakistan Customs: Mobilizing Domestic Revenues for Economic Development. Government Notes: 1.


Povratni linkovi

  • Trenutno nema povratnih linkova