ROBERT BORK I PROBLEM SUDSKE DIKTATURE

Miša Đurković

Sažetak


Autor ovog članka se bavi problemom sudske diktature. U pitanju je tendencija sudske vlasti u zapadnim zemljama, a pre svega u Sjedinjenim Američkim Državama (SAD), da uzurpira i nelegalno preuzima ingerencije zakonodavne vlasti. Sudije to rade da bi promovisale antitradicionalne levičarske vrednosti. Autor posebno izdvaja rad sudije Roberta Borka koji je pokazao kako se istovremeno odvijaju oba ta procesa i kako veliku ulogu sudije imaju u takozvanim kulturnim ratovima. Detaljno se obrađuju metodi i slučajevi u kojima je Vrhovni sud SAD u poslednjih sedamdeset godina menjao vrednosni, politički pa i ustavni sistem SAD, donošenjem neustavnih odluka. Na kraju se predstavlja i tzv. originalističko tumačenje sudske prakse za koje se Bork zalagao.


Pojmovne odrednice


Sudije; Sudska diktatura; Levica; Rober Bork; Originalizam

Ceo tekst:

PDF DOI

Reference


Bickel, A., The Least Dangerous Branch, Bobbs-Merrill, Indianapolis 1962.

Bork, R., The Tempting of America, A Touchstone Books, New York 1990.

Bork, R., „Courts and the Culture Wars“, Courts and the Culture Wars (ed. B. C. S. Watson), Lexington Books, Minneapolis 2002.

Bork, R., Coercing Virtue, The Worldwide Rule of Judges, AEI, Wa­shington 2003.

Bork, R. (ed.), A Country I do not Recognize, Hoover Institution Press, Stanford 2005.

Đurković, M., Poredak, moral i ljudska prava, Institut za evropske studije, Beograd 2001. (Đurković, M., Poredak, moral i ljudska prava, Institut za evropske studije, Beograd 2001)

Đurković, M., Ideologija, partije i međunarodni odnosi, IPS, Beograd 2012. (Đurković, M., Ideologija, partije i međunarodni odnosi, IPS, Beograd 2012)

Eastland, T., „A Court Tilting against Religious Liberty“, A Country I do not Recognize (ed. R. Bork), Hoover Institution Press, Stanford 2005.

Eastman, J, „Stare Decisis: Conservatism’s One Way Ratchet Problem“, Courts and the Culture Wars (ed. B. C. S. Watson), Lexington Books, Minneapolis 2002.

Erler, E. J., „The California Supreme Court in the Culture Wars: A Case Study in Judicial Failure“, Courts and the Culture Wars (ed. B. C. S. Watson), Lexington Books, Minneapolis 2002.

Graglia, L. A., „Constitutional Law without the Constitution: The Supreme Court’s remaking of America“, A Country I do not Recognize (ed. R. Bork), Hoover Institution Press, Stanford 2005.

Hirschl, R., Towards Juristocracy: The Origins and Consequences of the New Constitutionalism, Harvard University Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts 2004.

Holland, K. (ed.), Judicial Activism in Comparative Perspective, Palgrave Macmillan, London 1991.

Hunter, J. D., Culture Wars: The Struggle to Define America, Basic books, New York 1992.

McDowel, G. L., „The Perverse Paradox of Privacy“, A Country I do not Recognize (ed. R. Bork), Hoover Institution Press, Stanford 2005.

Neuhaus, R. J. et al., „The End of Democracy? Introduction“, The First Things Magazine 9/1996.

O’Reilly, B., Culture Warrior, Broadway Books, Portland 2006.

Pinelli, C., „Gouvernement des Judges“, Petite Histoire du Terme“, 2009, www.umk.ro/images/documente/publicatii/masarotunda2009/13_gouvernement.pdf, 12. februar 2018.

Quirk, W., Bridwell, R., Judicial Dictatorship, Transaction Publishers, New Jersey 1995.

Šmit, K., Norma i odluka: Karl Šmit i njegovi kritičari, Filip Višnjić, Beograd 2001. (Šmit, K., Norma i odluka: Karl Šmit i njegovi kritičari, Filip Višnjić, Beograd 2001)

Tate, N., Vallinder, T. (eds.), The Global Expansion of Judicial Power, New York University Press, New York 1997.

Vieira, N., Gross, L., Supreme Court Appointments, Judge Bork and the Politicization of Senate Confirmations, Southern Illinois University Press, Carbondale, Illinois 1998.

Walker, G., „Religious Freedom without Religious Neutrality: Our Once and Future Constitutional Common Sense“, Courts and the Culture Wars (ed. B. C. S. Watson), Lexington Books, Minneapolis 2002.

Watson, B. C. S. (ed.), Courts and the Culture Wars, Lexington Books, Minneapolis 2002.

Whittington, K. E., „The Death of the Legalized Constitution and the Spectre of Judicial Review“, Courts and the Culture Wars (ed. B. C. S. Watson), Lexington Books, Minneapolis 2002.

Wolfe, C., „From Constitutional Interpretation to Judicial Activism: The Transformation of Judicial Review in America“, The Heritage Foundation Report 2006, http://www.heritage.org/node/ 16876/print-display, 18. mart 2018.


Povratni linkovi

  • Trenutno nema povratnih linkova